After a loyal Bullblog reader pointed out that the pastries at Atticus and Willoughby’s look suspiciously similar to those at Judie’s, I decided to do some sleuthing.

We’re sad the muffins aren’t on sale, but still — Dark Chocolate Chip Delight cupcakes? Aztec brownies? Oatmeal Cranberry cookies? Peanut Butter truffles? Okay, Atticus. We feel you.